When Lady Cecily Burkhart loses her parents to a mysterious illness in 1527, she becomes Baroness Burkhart, but being only eight-years-old, she also becomes the ward to the Earl of Sumerton, Harold Pierce. The Pierce family - Lord Hal, Lady Grace, Mirabella, Brey, and Father Alec Cahill - all kindly welcome Cecily into their home and into their lives. Despite a dark secret or two of the family’s, Cecily has some happy years there and looks forward to her future.
But tragedy strikes the family twice over, and it alters Cecily’s future and Mirabella’s vocation is taken from her because of Henry VIII’s religious reforms. From then on, Cecily, growing into a young woman, tries to hold the family together while Mirabella does everything she can to destroy them.
The Sumerton Women took place in a time of Henry VIII’s reign that was rapidly growing more volatile. He uprooted England’s whole world by putting aside Catherine of Aragon in order to freely be with Anne Boleyn as he petitioned for a divorce that the pope would never grant. Anne had already brought with her some safe reformer reviews and Henry would do anything to have her and a legitimate male heir, so religious upheaval was not out of the question. He broke from Rome, made himself the head of his own church, made Thomas Cranmer the archbishop of Canterbury, and got the divorce he wanted. He also unleashed something that he had not foreseen; his actions opened the door for more fervent reformers to promote the New Learning. Besides the desired divorce, King Henry only wanted to be the head of his own reformed Catholic church. England’s first Protestant ruler was his son, Edward VI.
All of this is the backdrop for D.L. Bogdan’s larger story about Cecily and the Pierce family, who deal with the issue of religion as well as the more prominent themes of family and personal motivations.
Cecily vaguely remembered that her parents spoke of the New Learning with curiosity and her own mind was open. Mirabella, a few years older than Cecily, was a strict Catholic, except for the hate she harbored in her heart. Brey’s views were unknown, but he did not take after his sister. Their father, Hal, wore a hair shirt under his clothes to atone for his secret sin, but he enjoyed having fun and he was friendly and jovial. His wife Grace, however, resented the Catholic faith and tended to agree with the New Learning, but she was not religious enough to put any effort into either. Father Alec was cautious as he came to believe more in the New Learning. The household represented varying degrees of religious belief and was just a small sample of what was happening in Tudor England at the time.
Along with religion, themes of tragedy and renewal reappear throughout The Sumerton Women. Bogdan produced an action-packed and fast-paced historical fiction novel that readers can easily and happily lose themselves in. I definitely rode the waves of emotion and the trials of life throughout this whole novel and I cared about all of the characters, even Mirabella, despite how much I hated her for the majority of the novel because of all her horrible actions.
The Sumerton Women is a book of intertwined destinies, a book of joy, heartache, forbidden attraction, betrayal, and almost unbelievable secrets with some mentions and a cameo of Tudor England’s elite.
Recommended for historical fiction readers eighteen and up. There is nothing too controversial within these pages.